1. Home

Product groups

Support

external storage of SFTP public-key authentication - WeOnlyDo Discussion board

external storage of SFTP public-key authentication (wodSFTP / wodSFTP.NET / wodSFTPdll)

by Dennis Griesser, Friday, February 04, 2005, 03:11 (7231 days ago)

We have used your SFTP component with good results for a couple of years. Our product is written in PowerBuilder. Now we are trying to add public-key authentication. This question concerns use of the WeOnlyDo.Keys object. I'm not up to an actual SFTP yet.

I can instantiate the WeOnlyDo.Keys object in PowerBuilder. I can get it to Generate() keys. I can use Save() to export the keys.

But I want to do my own key storage by accessing the PrivateKey(KeyType) property.

Question #1 - The PublicKey property is read-only. If I assign a value to PrivateKey, will the corresponding PublicKey be generated? If not, how are we supposed to persist keys across sessions (without writing to a file)?

Question #2 - I am unable to get meaningful data from PrivateKey. If I Generate(DSA) and examine PrivateKey(RSA), I get an exception (good; that particular key type has no value). If I Generate(DSA) and examine PrivateKey(DSA), I get back a string (good) that has zero-length (bad).

[The environment is PowerBuilder 8.0.2, using your latest trial download of wodSFTP.exe, 2.2.1.]

locked
  2307 views

Re: external storage of SFTP public-key authentica

by Dennis Griesser, Friday, February 04, 2005, 19:30 (7231 days ago) @ Dennis Griesser

I might have part of the answer to my own questions.

PowerBuilder may be storing strings in memory with null termination. If so, the first time it hits a zero, it thinks the string is over. And the (binary) key is likely to have a zero sooner or later, making string manipulation useless.

I have tried the PrivateKeyData(KeyType) property, and it returns a blob with nonzero length.

If you agree, this leaves only a modified form of Question #1 - If I assign a value to PrivateKeyData, will the corresponding PublicKey be generated? If not, how are we supposed to persist keys across sessions (without writing to a file)?

locked
  2301 views

Re: external storage of SFTP public-key authentica

by wodSupport, Saturday, February 05, 2005, 11:08 (7230 days ago) @ Dennis Griesser

Dennis,

hi. Forget about public key - you need it only to paste to a server (to a corresponding file), and you don't need to keep it locally. Anyway, you can always derive it from the private key.

As for storing private key, yes, you're right, result of PrivateKey property returns raw data that may cause problems in some environments. But, latest version of wodKeys does allow you to specify PEM format of the key (base64 encoded) instead od raw data. So, if you need to keep it somehow in your app, you could Save it once, and then pass saved value (this will be base64 data, easy to keep in your app) to Load method.

locked
  2226 views

Thank you so much for your hard work and commitment in producing well thought-out solutions. WeOnlyDo is very committed to customer satisfaction!

Mike McPherson
Nokia Inc.

I would highly recommend this to anyone who needs a good quality SFTP solution.

Ian D. Mead, author of UltraEdit-32
IDM Computer Solutions

May I say how nice it is to work with components so complete and self-explanatory that using them in my application is as instinctive as though I wrote them myself?

Michael Barnett
Full Spectrum Telecommunications

Brilliant, even works on the mobile phone...

Conrad Leigh
Leaf Wireless

...what I really like is that wodSSH and wodSFTP components work excellently and are constantly being improved...

Steven Jones
SABIEN project

Thank you so much for your hard work and commitment in producing well thought-out solutions. WeOnlyDo is very committed to customer satisfaction!

Mike McPherson
Nokia Inc.

WeOnlyDo!COM will be the first stop I make should I require any further off-the-shelf components.

Dean Keigan
RBC Capital Markets

Thank you very much for the rapid responses. I was a little nervous about dealing with a company that is on a different continent from me. You have proven my concerns to be unfounded.

Robert Pacheco
Surebridge, Inc.

The wodCrypt product is great and we appreciate your effort to add support for UNIX Crypt.

William Ruf
Siemens Information and Communication Networks

Not only wodSFTPdll is excellent, the service you have provided is outstanding and second to none!

Ian D. Mead, author of UltraEdit-32
IDM Computer Solutions